How to Pass the Homeschool Test in West Virginia: The 4th Stanine Explained

West Virginia is one of the few states with a clear, numeric benchmark for homeschool testing: your child must score at or above the 4th stanine on a standardized test. That requirement applies in grades 3, 5, 8, and 11. If you're new to WV homeschool law, the word "stanine" probably needs unpacking before anything else.

What Is the 4th Stanine?

Stanine stands for "standard nine." It's a nine-point scale used to normalize standardized test scores across different assessments. Stanines work like this:

• Stanines 1-3: Below average
• Stanines 4-6: Average range
• Stanines 7-9: Above average

The 4th stanine corresponds roughly to the 23rd to 39th percentile — the low end of the average range. So when WV law requires performance at or above the 4th stanine, it's setting a floor of approximately the 23rd percentile nationally. A student at the 4th stanine is not failing by any measure — they're performing in the lower-average range.

This is a meaningful distinction for parents who panic when they hear "your child has to pass a test." The benchmark is not a pass/fail cutoff like a state achievement test. Most homeschooled children who receive consistent instruction across the five required subject areas will meet the 4th stanine threshold without special test preparation.

Which Tests Count?

West Virginia Code §18-8-1 requires a "nationally normed standardized test." The statute does not restrict families to a specific test. Commonly used tests that qualify include:

• Iowa Assessments (ITBS) — widely used, available through private testing providers
• Stanford Achievement Test (SAT-10 or similar) — not the college SAT; a separate achievement test
• California Achievement Test (CAT) — available for home administration in some forms
• Terra Nova — normed assessment available through testing services

Many WV families use a testing service rather than administering the test themselves. Organizations like Christian Home Educators of West Virginia (CHEWV) sometimes coordinate group testing days, which reduce the per-student cost. Independent evaluators and learning centers in the state also offer standardized test administration.

The test must be nationally normed — meaning it benchmarks your child against a national sample of students at the same grade level. A curriculum-based quiz or portfolio rubric does not satisfy the standardized test requirement on its own.

When Do You Actually Need to Test?

Assessment is required in grades 3, 5, 8, and 11 only. You are not required to test every year. In between assessment grades, you teach normally and maintain your annual Notice of Intent — no test required.

The practical calendar looks like this:

• Grade 3: First assessment year. Results submitted to county superintendent.
• Grades 4, 6, 7, 9, 10: No testing required under state law.
• Grade 5, 8, 11: Assessment required again.

You submit your assessment results to the county superintendent after each required assessment year. The county does not evaluate your results against a pass/fail standard in the traditional sense — they receive confirmation that testing occurred and that your child met or exceeded the 4th stanine threshold.

What Happens If Your Child Scores Below the 4th Stanine?

This is the question that causes the most anxiety, and the answer is more nuanced than most families expect.

West Virginia law does not automatically remove homeschool status if a child scores below the 4th stanine once. However, the statute does contemplate a remediation process. In practice, a score below the threshold typically triggers a review conversation with the county superintendent's office — and may require you to demonstrate what instructional changes you're making to address the gap.

There is also an alternative to standardized testing: portfolio review. Under §18-8-1(c)(2), families can choose to have a certified teacher or licensed evaluator review a portfolio of the child's work instead of submitting standardized test results. If you anticipate that your child will struggle with the testing format — due to test anxiety, a learning difference, or the particular demands of a standardized test environment — the portfolio route may be more appropriate.

The two options are not mutually exclusive. Some families use standardized testing in early assessment years and switch to portfolio review later, or vice versa.

Portfolio Review as an Alternative

Portfolio review involves assembling a collection of your child's work from the school year — writing samples, math assignments, science projects, reading logs — and having a licensed evaluator assess whether the work demonstrates grade-appropriate progress. The evaluator submits a written report to the county superintendent confirming that the child is making academic progress.

This route puts more preparation responsibility on the parent (you need to maintain organized records throughout the year) but removes the standardized test anxiety factor. If your child has an IEP or significant learning differences, portfolio review is often the better fit.

The Hope Scholarship and Testing

If your child receives WV Hope Scholarship funds, the program's accountability requirements tie into the same assessment framework. Hope Scholarship students must demonstrate academic progress annually — which, in practice, means meeting the same 4th stanine standard or completing a portfolio review. Failing to meet the accountability requirement can affect continued scholarship eligibility.

The WD09 code (standard homeschool) and WDHOPE code (Hope Scholarship participants) are tracked separately by the state. If you're using the scholarship, confirm with your scholarship coordinator which assessment documentation they require in addition to the county superintendent submission.

Practical Tips for the Assessment Year

Start earlier than you think. Many families treat assessment years as a surprise. If you know grade 3 is coming, start thinking about which test provider you'll use six months out. Scheduling fills up, especially if you're using a group testing day organized by a local co-op.

Keep records throughout the year. Whether you're planning to test or do portfolio review, having consistent documentation of instruction throughout the year is far more useful than cramming at the end. An attendance log with subject notes takes five minutes a day to maintain.

Know your test. Different nationally normed tests weight subjects differently. The Iowa Assessments and Stanford Achievement Test are both solid choices with strong national norming samples. Spend time with practice materials so your child understands the format before test day — this reduces score variability from test-taking confusion rather than actual knowledge gaps.

Understand what's being measured. The 4th stanine is not a high bar. It's the 23rd percentile nationally. Children who receive attentive, consistent instruction in the five required subjects (math, reading/language arts, science, social studies, health) will typically land well above this threshold without intensive test prep.

If you're navigating WV's assessment requirements for the first time — or figuring out how assessment fits into your overall compliance picture — the West Virginia Legal Withdrawal Blueprint covers the full framework: NOI filing, assessment options, county-specific considerations, and what to do if your county board pushes back.

See more United States homeschool guides →