South Carolina's Three Homeschool Options: What Each Law Actually Requires

Most states have one homeschooling law. South Carolina has three — and each one puts you in a completely different legal relationship with the state, your local school district, and an accountability organization. That's the source of nearly every question new SC homeschoolers ask.

The three options are not tiers of the same system. They are separate statutory pathways, codified in different sections of the South Carolina Code of Laws, each with its own requirements, oversight structure, and level of educational freedom. Understanding the difference before you withdraw your child is the single most important thing you can do to avoid truancy complications.

Option 1: District Oversight (SC Code §59-65-40)

Option 1 is the oldest pathway and, by a wide margin, the least used. It operates under §59-65-40 and puts the local public school district's board of trustees directly in charge of approving and monitoring your home education program.

The compliance burden under Option 1 is substantial. Parents must:

• Maintain a detailed plan book or diary documenting subjects taught and activities completed
• Keep a portfolio of academic work samples throughout the year
• Submit a semiannual progress report — including attendance records and individual subject assessments — directly to the school district at the end of each semester

The deepest problem with Option 1 is the testing requirement. Students in a district-approved program must participate in the same statewide assessments given to public school students (SC READY, SC PASS, and the Basic Skills Assessment Program), and those tests must be administered by a certified district employee. If a student scores below the district's promotion standards, the board of trustees has statutory authority to mandate re-enrollment in the public school system or require the parent to fund specialized instruction at their own expense.

That risk of forced re-enrollment is why legal advocates and homeschooling organizations almost universally steer families away from Option 1. Most families who end up in Option 1 did so without fully understanding what they were signing up for.

Option 2: SCAIHS (SC Code §59-65-45)

Option 2 was created to give homeschoolers a path free from district oversight. Instead of reporting to the local school board, families operating under §59-65-45 come under the oversight of a single, specifically named private organization: the South Carolina Association of Independent Home Schools (SCAIHS).

SCAIHS is not a government agency. It is a private, non-profit organization that provides curriculum guidance, educational counseling, official transcript generation, and diploma services. Because the code names SCAIHS specifically — it is the only organization authorized to provide Option 2 oversight — there is no equivalent "Option 2 with a different association." SCAIHS is Option 2.

The tradeoffs are real. SCAIHS membership starts at approximately $425 annually for the first child, with additional fees for each additional child. Families must meet SCAIHS's own internal reporting standards, which typically involve submitting grades, attendance records, and curriculum overviews to assigned counselors. SCAIHS also requires standardized testing for students in grades 3 through 11.

For families who want heavy administrative support, professional college admissions assistance, and an official association-backed diploma and transcript, Option 2 is a legitimate premium choice. For families who want maximum curriculum freedom and privacy from oversight, it is expensive and more restrictive than Option 3.

Option 3: Third-Option Accountability Associations (SC Code §59-65-47)

Option 3 is the dominant choice — the overwhelming majority of South Carolina homeschooling families use this pathway. It operates under §59-65-47, which states that parents may homeschool their children if the instruction is conducted "under the auspices of an association for home schools which has no fewer than fifty members."

This is the critical phrase. The law does not name any specific organization. Any accountability association with at least 50 members can operate as a legitimate Option 3 association, and there are dozens of them across the state ranging from large statewide groups to small county-level co-ops. Some charge as little as $10 to $25 per year in membership dues.

Under Option 3, parents maintain their own records — a plan book indicating subjects taught, a portfolio of work samples, and a semiannual progress report covering attendance and academic progress in each instructional area. These records are held by the parent, not submitted to the state Department of Education or the local school district. The local district has no authority over Option 3 families and no right to review your curriculum, conduct home visits, or demand approval before you begin.

State standardized testing is entirely optional under Option 3. This is a meaningful distinction from both Options 1 and 2: no one from the state or the district can compel you to test.

Why the Three Options Cause Confusion

The confusion most families experience when researching SC homeschool law traces back to one root cause: Option 1 is still on the books, and its language about district "approval" bleeds into people's assumptions about Options 2 and 3. School administrators sometimes operate under the same misunderstanding — occasionally telling parents they need to "approve" a family's curriculum or conduct an exit interview before releasing a child's records. Under Options 2 and 3, this is legally inaccurate. No district approval is required.

A second source of confusion is the role of SCAIHS. Because SCAIHS is specifically named in state code, many families assume it is a government regulatory body. It is not. It is a private organization, and its oversight authority applies only to the families who voluntarily enroll under Option 2.

The third source of confusion — and the most consequential right now — is the Education Scholarship Trust Fund (ESTF). South Carolina's $7,500 personalized learning scholarship operates under a completely separate section of law (SC Code §59-8-115). Families enrolled in any Option 1, 2, or 3 association are strictly ineligible to participate in the ESTF while maintaining that association membership. The two programs cannot be combined.

Choosing Your Option Before You Withdraw

The order of operations matters. South Carolina's compulsory attendance law (§59-65-10) covers children aged five through seventeen continuously. A gap in enrollment — where a child has left a public or private school but has not yet registered with a legal homeschool option — creates a truancy liability.

This means you need to select and register with your chosen option before you notify the school of your withdrawal. Once your association membership or district registration is confirmed, you obtain your withdrawal documentation and then formally notify the school. The sequence protects you.

For the vast majority of families, that means joining an Option 3 association first, receiving your membership letter and withdrawal documentation from the association, and then presenting that documentation to the school.

If you want a step-by-step walkthrough of the full withdrawal process — including the exact chronological sequence, administrator pushback scripts, and fill-in templates that cite the specific SC code sections — the South Carolina Legal Withdrawal Blueprint covers every piece of the process in one place.

See more United States homeschool guides →