Secular Microschool Pennsylvania: Starting a Non-Religious Learning Pod Under Act 169

Parents searching for a secular microschool in Pennsylvania quickly notice a gap: the dominant, well-organized homeschool infrastructure in the state is religious. The Christian Homeschool Association of Pennsylvania (CHAP) has decades of experience, extensive evaluator directories, and co-op frameworks built for faith-based families. What it does not provide is a model for the growing number of parents who want rigorous, community-based alternative education with no religious content woven through it.

That gap is closing. Secular pods and cooperatives are expanding across the Lehigh Valley, Philadelphia suburbs, and Lancaster County. The Rising Roots Secular Homeschool Cooperative in the Lehigh Valley now supports 78 enrolled families and 161 children — a scale that demonstrates secular pods are not a fringe category. They are a growing and increasingly organized segment of Pennsylvania's alternative education landscape.

Why Secular Families Are Forming Pods Rather Than Staying Solo

The pattern is consistent: a secular family withdraws from public school, attempts solo homeschooling under Act 169, and encounters two compounding problems.

The first is administrative burden. Pennsylvania requires each homeschooling family to file a notarized affidavit with their local superintendent by August 1st each year, maintain a contemporaneous instructional log, manage a portfolio of student work, and arrange an annual evaluation by a certified evaluator. Doing this for multiple children, while also delivering instruction across Pennsylvania's mandated ten-plus subject areas, is genuinely exhausting when one parent is handling everything.

The second is isolation. Secular families looking for co-op support in many Pennsylvania counties find that the established co-ops are CHAP-affiliated or operate with explicit religious frameworks. Joining a faith-based group is not a neutral administrative choice — the curriculum selections, the evaluator networks, the community culture, and even the tone of portfolio review advice are shaped by the religious orientation of the organization. A secular family can participate, but it involves continuous friction.

Forming a secular pod with a small group of like-minded families solves both problems: it distributes the administrative load and creates a community with aligned values.

The Legal Structure for Secular Pods in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania law does not distinguish between religious and secular home education programs. Both operate under the same 24 PA C.S. §13-1327.1 framework. A secular microschool uses exactly the same legal structure as a faith-based cooperative — which is also the structure that makes secular pods clean to operate.

Under Act 169, each family files independently. The microschool does not file a collective affidavit; it exists as an informal cooperative or a tutoring arrangement hired collectively by individual homeschooling families. Each family retains its own legal compliance responsibility — the affidavit, the portfolio, the evaluator appointment. The pod provides the shared physical space, the group instruction, and the centralized scheduling.

This matters for secular founders because it means the pod does not need to register with any state authority as a religious or secular institution. There is no application, no approval, no oversight of the pod's pedagogical orientation. A secular pod teaching entirely through evidence-based science, secular history, and non-religious literature is operating identically to a faith-based pod that uses Bible-integrated materials — both are groups of homeschooling families who have chosen to share instructional resources.

The one constraint that applies regardless of religious orientation is the DHS "unrelated children" rule. In a residential home, gathering more than four to six children who are unrelated to the homeowner creates the legal definition of unlicensed family day care under 55 Pa. Code. Secular pods that want to meet more frequently or with larger groups typically rent space from a community center, library meeting room, or church (which will rent to non-members), or use a rotating parent-present model where each session has a parent from each family on-site.

Curriculum Freedom Is the Core Advantage

The secular pod's greatest structural advantage is total curriculum freedom. Pennsylvania's Act 169 requires that homeschooled students receive instruction in a defined list of subjects — English, arithmetic, science, geography, U.S. and Pennsylvania history, civics, safety education, health and physiology, physical education, music, and art — but it does not specify which curriculum materials must be used, which pedagogical methods must be applied, or what religious (or secular) perspective the instruction must take.

For secular families, this means a pod can build its entire curriculum around secular resources without any state interference. History can be taught through primary sources and evidence-based historiography. Science can be taught without content that conflicts with evolutionary biology or cosmology. Literature selections do not require any religious lens. The pod can integrate living books, project-based learning, Socratic discussion, and hands-on experimentation — or a structured secular curriculum package — entirely at the discretion of the founding families.

Popular secular curricula among Pennsylvania pods include Easy Peasy All-in-One Homeschool (free, web-based, explicitly secular), Timberdoodle, and Blossom and Root. For families running a more structured academic environment, Moving Beyond the Page and Time4Learning offer complete secular packages.

Finding Secular Evaluators

Portfolio evaluation is where secular families sometimes encounter unexpected friction. Pennsylvania certifies evaluators from a range of backgrounds, and a portion of the evaluator pool comes through CHAP and similar religious organizations. An evaluator with strong religious commitments reviewing a secular portfolio is typically neutral on that point — their legal obligation is to certify whether the portfolio demonstrates appropriate academic progress, not to assess the religious content of the curriculum.

However, secular families founding pods should ask evaluators directly about their experience with secular and alternative portfolios. A evaluator who is unfamiliar with project-based or non-textbook portfolios may ask for documentation in formats the family has not produced. The question "Are you comfortable evaluating a portfolio without a traditional textbook or worksheet format?" surfaces this mismatch before the June 30th evaluation deadline rather than during it.

Evaluator directories beyond CHAP include The Dandelion Project and Pennsylvania Homeschoolers Accreditation Agency (PHAA), both of which maintain lists of evaluators with broader experience. Group evaluation arrangements — where a pod books one evaluator for all families on a single day — typically cost between $30 and $100 per student and allow the evaluator to build familiarity with the pod's educational approach across the whole group.

Building the Secular Pod Community

Secular pods in Pennsylvania currently coalesce through a few channels. Facebook groups organized by county often have secular-specific threads or subgroups — searching "[county name] secular homeschool" or "[county name] secular co-op" surfaces active communities in most metropolitan areas. Reddit's r/homeschool and r/Pennsylvania have active secular homeschooling threads with Pennsylvania-specific advice.

In the Philadelphia suburbs and Lehigh Valley, the density of secular-leaning families is high enough that founding a pod often requires only a few posts in the right community spaces to identify four to eight families with compatible schedules and educational values. In more rural counties, the realistic starting point may be a two or three family arrangement that expands as word spreads.

The practical infrastructure a secular pod needs before its first day of instruction: a signed learning pod agreement that specifies each family's responsibilities under Act 169, a clear schedule that counts toward the 180-day requirement, a vetted evaluator booked for late spring, and a space that complies with local zoning rules. None of this requires religious affiliation of any kind.

For founders who want the legal frameworks, template documents, and compliance checklists built specifically for Pennsylvania's Act 169 structure — including the parent agreement, facilitator contract, and evaluator coordination protocols — the Pennsylvania Micro-School & Pod Kit provides the operational architecture without prescribing any curriculum or philosophical orientation. Secular or otherwise, the legal structure is the same.

What Secular Pods Look Like in Practice

The Lehigh Valley's Rising Roots model offers a concrete example of what a secular cooperative at scale looks like: 78 families, 161 children, organized around inclusive values and non-religious instruction. That scale is the exception at the founding stage, not the expectation. Most secular pods begin with four to eight students, meet two to four days per week, and grow through parent referrals as families verify the model actually works for their children.

What distinguishes a well-run secular pod from an informal playgroup is documentation. Pennsylvania's Act 169 compliance burden does not relax because a family is part of a group. Each family's portfolio must independently demonstrate 180 days of instruction across the required subjects. A pod that coordinates this documentation centrally — tracking group learning activities by subject, maintaining attendance logs, and organizing portfolio materials throughout the year rather than in a June scramble — provides genuine administrative relief to its families rather than just social relief.

That operational discipline is what separates sustainable pods from the ones that dissolve by December. Building it in from the start is what makes the secular microschool model viable at any scale.

See more United States homeschool guides →