SCAIHS vs Option 3: Which South Carolina Homeschool Path Is Right for You?
SCAIHS and Option 3 are the two most common legal pathways for South Carolina homeschoolers, and they serve genuinely different needs. Picking the wrong one doesn't make you illegal — both are fully recognized under SC law — but it can mean spending $400 more per year than you need to, or missing out on services that would actually make your homeschool easier.
Here's what separates them.
What SCAIHS Is (and Isn't)
SCAIHS — the South Carolina Association of Independent Home Schools — is a private, non-profit organization that is specifically named in SC Code §59-65-45. That's why operating under SCAIHS is called "Option 2." It is the only organization authorized by name in state law to provide Option 2 oversight. There is no equivalent.
SCAIHS is not a government agency. It is not affiliated with the SC Department of Education. It is a premium membership organization that provides academic counseling, curriculum guidance, official transcript generation, diploma services, and formal record-keeping. When a SCAIHS family applies to college, the transcript comes from SCAIHS — which carries its own institutional credibility with many admissions offices.
The price reflects the service level. SCAIHS membership starts at approximately $425 per year for one child, with an additional $55 or so for each subsequent child. That is the baseline — it does not include fees for additional SCAIHS services like NCAA certification, diploma processing, or official record retrieval.
What Option 3 Associations Are
Option 3 operates under SC Code §59-65-47. The statute requires that instruction be conducted "under the auspices of an association for home schools which has no fewer than fifty members." Any organization that meets that 50-member threshold qualifies as a legal Option 3 accountability association.
There are dozens of active Option 3 associations in South Carolina. Some are large statewide networks; others are small county-level groups. Annual dues range from roughly $10 on the low end to $100 for associations that offer more extensive services like co-op access, portfolio consulting, or legal advocacy resources. The SC Department of Education maintains a current list of active Option 3 associations.
Option 3 associations provide accountability — they verify that member families are maintaining required records and complying with the law — but they do not direct your curriculum, mandate your teaching methods, or require specific standardized tests. The educational content is entirely your decision.
The Core Differences
Cost. This is the most significant practical difference for most families. SCAIHS starts at $425 per year. Option 3 associations start at $10 and typically top out around $75 to $100 for the most service-heavy options. The cost differential is meaningful: a family running a tight budget executing a mid-year emergency withdrawal can join an Option 3 association, be legal, and start homeschooling for the price of a grocery run.
Standardized testing. SCAIHS requires standardized testing for students in grades 3 through 11. This is one of the most significant operational constraints for SCAIHS families. Under Option 3, there is no state mandate for standardized testing at all. Many Option 3 families voluntarily use nationally norm-referenced tests like the Iowa Tests of Basic Skills (ITBS) or the Stanford Achievement Test, but it is their choice, not a legal requirement.
Reporting structure. SCAIHS families submit grades, attendance records, and curriculum overviews to assigned SCAIHS counselors on a regular schedule. This is a more intensive ongoing reporting relationship than most Option 3 associations require. Option 3 parents maintain their own plan book, portfolio, and semiannual progress reports — held by the parent, not submitted to the state or district.
Transcript and diploma services. This is where SCAIHS provides clear value for high school families. SCAIHS handles official transcript generation and diploma issuance as part of their service. For families planning college applications, particularly to selective institutions or programs with NCAA eligibility requirements, having an SCAIHS-backed transcript carries weight. Under Option 3, parents generate their own transcripts and diplomas — which is entirely legal and accepted by most colleges, but requires the parent to take ownership of that documentation.
Curriculum approval. SCAIHS provides counseling-based curriculum guidance and expects families to maintain curricula consistent with their academic standards. Option 3 associations have no curriculum approval authority. You can use any curriculum — traditional, eclectic, Charlotte Mason, unschooling philosophy — without anyone's permission.
District relationship. Under both Option 2 and Option 3, the local school district has no oversight authority over your homeschool. This is a key point: neither SCAIHS nor Option 3 families are subject to district approval, curriculum review, or mandatory state testing administered by district employees (all of which apply only to Option 1).
Free Download
Get the South Carolina Homeschool Quick-Start Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| SCAIHS (Option 2) | Option 3 Association | |
|---|---|---|
| Governing code | SC Code §59-65-45 | SC Code §59-65-47 |
| Annual cost (first child) | ~$425 | $10–$100 |
| Standardized testing | Required (grades 3–11) | Not required |
| Records submitted to | SCAIHS counselors | Maintained by parent |
| Official transcripts | Provided by SCAIHS | Parent-generated |
| Diploma services | Provided by SCAIHS | Parent-issued (or via some associations) |
| Curriculum oversight | SCAIHS counseling standards | None — parent's choice |
| District oversight | None | None |
Who SCAIHS Is Right For
SCAIHS is worth the premium for families who:
- Are homeschooling through high school and want official, institutionally-backed transcripts for college applications
- Want professional counseling support and don't mind a structured reporting relationship
- Are pursuing NCAA eligibility or scholarship applications that benefit from formal association documentation
- Want a complete "done with you" academic support system and are willing to pay for that level of service
Who Option 3 Is Right For
Option 3 is the better fit for families who:
- Want curriculum freedom without any organization reviewing or guiding their choices
- Don't want mandatory standardized testing obligations
- Are executing a mid-year emergency withdrawal and need to get legal quickly and affordably
- Are comfortable maintaining their own records and generating their own documentation
- Want to spend their homeschool budget on curriculum, co-ops, and enrichment rather than administrative fees
The majority of South Carolina homeschoolers choose Option 3 for all of the above reasons. It is not a lesser option — it is a different one, and for most families it provides the right balance of legal protection and educational freedom.
One Thing Both Paths Share
Whether you choose SCAIHS or an Option 3 association, the sequence for withdrawing from public school is the same: enroll with your chosen organization first, receive your withdrawal documentation from them, and then notify the school. The association or SCAIHS membership establishes your legal standing before you break ties with the school. This order of operations is what prevents truancy complications.
If you're working through the withdrawal process and want a complete step-by-step guide — including which Option 3 associations to consider, what to include in your withdrawal notification, and how to handle administrator pushback — the South Carolina Legal Withdrawal Blueprint covers the full process with SC-specific legal templates.
Get Your Free South Carolina Homeschool Quick-Start Checklist
Download the South Carolina Homeschool Quick-Start Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.