PEI's Amish Homeschool Community and the 2015 Law Change

Prince Edward Island has a small but established Amish community — one that most people driving through Charlottetown or Summerside would not immediately think of as a significant force in shaping provincial education policy. But in 2015, it was. Understanding why matters for every family on the Island considering homeschooling today.

What PEI's Home Education Law Looked Like Before 2015

Prior to 2015, PEI's home education framework required parents to submit a formal home education plan to the provincial government. That plan had to be reviewed and approved by a certified teacher employed by or affiliated with the Department of Education.

This created a significant practical barrier. A parent who wanted to homeschool had to:

1. Develop a written curriculum and educational plan in advance
2. Submit it to the Department for review
3. Await approval before legally beginning home instruction
4. Operate with the ongoing possibility that the Department could require modifications

For most parents, this was administratively burdensome. For the Amish community specifically, it was deeply problematic. Amish educational philosophy centers on apprenticeship learning, agricultural training, and the development of practical life skills within a specific religious and cultural framework. A secular, certified teacher reviewing their educational approach from the outside — and holding approval authority over it — was fundamentally incompatible with how the community understood education and parental authority.

The 2015 Change and What It Removed

Following requests from PEI's growing Amish community, the provincial government removed the teacher-approval requirement from the home education regulations. The current framework, established under the Home Education Regulations (EC526/16), operates on an entirely different model:

Notification only. Parents are required to submit a single "Notice of Intent" form to the Department of Education and Early Years before the start of the school year. That form requires only basic demographic information — the child's name and date of birth, the parent's contact details, and the last school attended.

No curriculum submission. Parents are not required to show the government what they plan to teach, which materials they will use, or which educational philosophy they will follow.

No teacher approval. No certified teacher reviews, approves, or has any formal role in the home education program.

No ongoing reporting. There are no mid-year status reports, end-of-year assessments, or required submissions to the Department.

The 2015 change transformed PEI from a moderate-regulation province to one of the lowest-regulation home education jurisdictions in Canada.

Why This Still Creates Confusion Today

The institutional memory of the pre-2015 regulations lingers. Some school principals — particularly those who have been in the system for more than a decade — retain mental models of what home education requires that predate the legal change. Occasionally, parents filing a withdrawal encounter administrators who ask for lesson plans, curriculum summaries, or proof of teaching qualifications.

These requests have no legal basis under the current regulations. Parents are not obligated to provide them. The confusion is real, but it is the school's confusion, not a legal requirement.

This dynamic is one of the reasons a PEI-specific withdrawal process matters. A parent who knows exactly what the 2016 regulations say — and can cite EC526/16 calmly and specifically — handles these situations very differently from a parent who is guessing based on outdated information they found on a general homeschooling website.

What the Amish Community's Experience Tells Us

The Amish request that drove the 2015 change illustrates something important about how PEI's home education system is understood at the policy level: the province genuinely accepts the principle that parents have the right to direct their children's education without state micromanagement.

That principle extends to all homeschooling families on the Island — not just religious communities. Whether you are homeschooling because of a bullying crisis, an unmet IEP, a philosophical disagreement with standardized curriculum, or a desire to align your child's education with a specific cultural or educational approach, the regulatory framework supports your right to do so.

The fact that the Amish community's specific needs prompted the legal simplification does not mean the benefits are restricted to them. PEI's current home education law is the most parent-controlled in the province's history, and it applies equally to every family who files a Notice of Intent.

The Current PEI Amish Homeschool Landscape

PEI's Amish community is centered primarily in the Kings County area of the Island. Families in this community generally homeschool within a communal framework, with instruction provided by community members rather than outside curriculum providers. Education focuses on practical skills, community values, and religious formation, typically concluding formal instruction at the eighth-grade level in keeping with Amish tradition.

For non-Amish families curious about homeschooling, the Amish model is illustrative in one specific way: it demonstrates that PEI's framework can accommodate the most radically different educational approach imaginable — and do so without conflict with the Department of Education — because the law simply does not require the state to approve what you are doing.

For the complete legal withdrawal process under PEI's current notification-based framework, the Prince Edward Island Legal Withdrawal Blueprint covers the Notice of Intent, the principal withdrawal letter, and everything you need to transition cleanly.

See more Canada homeschool guides →