Ontario School Board Sent You a Withdrawal Questionnaire? You Don't Have to Fill It Out
If your Ontario school board sent you a multi-page withdrawal form asking for your child's daily schedule, instructional activities, curriculum materials, and assessment methods—you do not have to complete it. That form is almost certainly Appendix D of Policy/Program Memorandum No. 131 (PPM 131), an investigative questionnaire that school boards are supposed to use only when they have specific grounds to suspect educational neglect. Sending it to all withdrawing families as a standard intake requirement is an overreach, and completing it voluntarily gives the board information it has no legal authority to demand.
What you are legally required to provide is a basic Letter of Intent containing your child's name, date of birth, gender, and your contact information—plus a declaration that you intend to provide home instruction under Section 21(2)(a) of the Education Act. That's it. The Ontario Legal Withdrawal Blueprint includes a pre-written Appendix D decline response that cites the specific sections of the Education Act and PPM 131 being overstepped.
What PPM 131 Actually Says About Appendix D
PPM 131 was issued by the Ontario Ministry of Education in 2002 to standardize how school boards handle homeschool notifications. It includes four appendices:
- Appendix A: Instructions to principals
- Appendix B: Sample notification letter for parents (the only form you're required to submit)
- Appendix C: Sample acknowledgment letter from the board (what the board sends you in return)
- Appendix D: Sample questionnaire for investigating whether satisfactory instruction is occurring
Appendix D exists for a specific purpose: when a school board has "reasonable grounds to suspect" that a child receiving home instruction is not receiving satisfactory education, they may investigate. The questionnaire is the tool for that investigation.
The problem is that dozens of Ontario school boards have incorporated Appendix D—or Appendix D-style questions—into their standard withdrawal intake forms, sending them to every withdrawing family alongside (or instead of) the basic notification process. Parents who receive a board-branded form in an official envelope from their school board assume it's mandatory. Many complete it without knowing they've just volunteered a detailed curriculum plan to an authority that had no legal basis to request one.
Why Completing Appendix D Harms You
It invites ongoing scrutiny. By submitting curriculum plans, daily schedules, and evaluation methods, you've given the board a baseline against which to measure your homeschooling. A board that's looking for reasons to question your program now has your own documentation to use against you.
It sets a precedent of compliance with unauthorized demands. If you complete the first form, the next communication asking for annual updates or home visit scheduling becomes harder to decline—you've already established that you respond to their requests.
It isn't legally required and creates no legal benefit. Completing Appendix D does not provide any legal protection, expedite your withdrawal, or improve your standing with the board. It only benefits the board's administrative data collection.
It conflates notification with investigation. The legal act of notification (Appendix B) exempts your child from compulsory attendance. Appendix D is investigation machinery that has no relevance to a family that has properly notified the board.
How to Identify an Appendix D Form
School board withdrawal forms vary by district, but Appendix D-style questions typically include requests for:
- Daily schedule or routine
- Instructional activities and methods
- Curriculum materials, textbooks, or online resources planned for use
- Assessment and evaluation methods
- Evidence of parent qualifications to teach
- Program planning documents
- Reasons for withdrawal
A form that asks for any of these—beyond basic identifying information—is requesting information you are not required to provide. The legal notification (Appendix B) requires only: child's name, date of birth, gender, parent/guardian name, home address, phone number, and intent to home-educate.
Free Download
Get the Ontario Homeschool Quick-Start Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
Comparison: What You Must Provide vs. What Boards Often Request
| Information | Required by Law? | Common Board Request? |
|---|---|---|
| Child's name | Yes | Yes |
| Child's date of birth | Yes | Yes |
| Child's gender | Yes | Yes |
| Parent/guardian name | Yes | Yes |
| Home address and phone | Yes | Yes |
| Declaration of intent to home-educate | Yes | Yes |
| Reasons for withdrawing | No | Often asked |
| Daily schedule | No | Often asked |
| Curriculum materials planned | No | Often asked |
| Assessment methods | No | Often asked |
| Parent's educational background | No | Sometimes asked |
| Proof of curriculum | No | Sometimes asked |
| Annual report or progress update | No | Sometimes implied |
What to Do When the Board Sends You an Appendix D Form
Step 1: Do not return their form.
Return it blank or decline to complete it in writing. Returning it partially completed still volunteers information you're not required to provide.
Step 2: Submit your own Letter of Intent separately.
Send your Letter of Intent—using only the legally required fields—by registered mail to the school board's home education or pupil records department. Do not send it to the principal's inbox.
Step 3: Send a written Appendix D decline response.
A written response that acknowledges receipt of the form, declines to complete it, and cites the specific legal basis for your decline creates a paper trail. This is especially important in adversarial situations.
The Ontario Legal Withdrawal Blueprint includes a ready-to-send Appendix D decline response citing the relevant sections of the Education Act and PPM 131. You can adapt it and send within the same day.
Step 4: Keep all correspondence.
If the board follows up to insist the form is mandatory, respond in writing referencing your letter and requesting they identify the specific statutory provision that requires completion. There isn't one.
Who Is Most Affected by the Appendix D Trap
Parents withdrawing from high-scrutiny situations. Families with adversarial relationships with their school (contested IEP meetings, bullying complaints, principal disputes) are more likely to face aggressive board follow-up. Completing Appendix D in these situations is particularly risky.
New immigrant families. Unfamiliarity with the Ontario legislative framework makes immigrants more likely to assume official-looking forms are mandatory. The Appendix D trap disproportionately affects families who assume government documents from the school board are legally binding.
Parents who found their withdrawal form on the school board's website. Many boards have incorporated Appendix D questions directly into their downloadable "Notice of Intent to Homeschool" forms. These forms look official and complete—but they're often the board's own creation, not a provincial requirement.
French Immersion exits. Parents leaving French Immersion for homeschooling sometimes receive both Form G (a school board transfer form) and an Appendix D-style questionnaire simultaneously, creating a confusing multi-form process when neither is actually required for a legal withdrawal.
The Annual Notification Trap
An extension of the Appendix D problem: PPM 131 states that ongoing homeschoolers should submit an annual notification letter before September 1 to confirm their continued intent to home-educate. Some school boards extend this into an annual Appendix D-style questionnaire, implying that families must provide curriculum updates and schedule information each year.
Annual notification is legitimately required. Annual Appendix D-style documentation is not. Your annual notification is the same basic letter as your initial Letter of Intent—not a progress report, curriculum update, or educational summary.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it illegal to refuse to complete the school board's withdrawal form?
No. Ontario law requires only that you submit a basic notification (Appendix B format). If the board's form goes beyond the legally required fields, you are legally permitted to decline to complete those additional sections. There is no penalty for declining to provide voluntarily requested information.
What if the board refuses to process my withdrawal until I return their form?
The board cannot legally condition your withdrawal on completing an Appendix D questionnaire. Submit your own Letter of Intent by registered mail addressed to the school board's home education department. Once delivered, the notification is legally effective regardless of what the board's administrative processing system does next. Keep your delivery tracking as documentation.
Can the board investigate me if I refuse to complete Appendix D?
An investigation under PPM 131 requires "reasonable grounds to suspect" that satisfactory instruction is not occurring. Declining to complete an unauthorized questionnaire is not, on its own, reasonable grounds for an investigation. If an investigation is initiated solely because you declined to complete a form you're not legally required to complete, that investigation itself is an overreach.
What if my board's Appendix D form asks for reasons for withdrawal?
Do not provide them. Reasons for withdrawal are not required under Ontario law. Including them in your submission invites engagement with your rationale—and gives the board a basis to push back or "counsel" you toward staying in the system.
Does completing Appendix D provide any legal benefit or protection?
No. Completing Appendix D does not expedite your withdrawal, create legal protection for your family, or improve your relationship with the school board. It only provides the board with information about your educational program. Ontario law does not require or reward this disclosure.
What do I send instead of the board's form?
You send your own Letter of Intent, using only the legally required fields. The Ontario Legal Withdrawal Blueprint includes a ready-to-use template that adheres strictly to Appendix B of PPM 131, includes every required field, and contains nothing that invites unnecessary scrutiny or additional board contact.
Get Your Free Ontario Homeschool Quick-Start Checklist
Download the Ontario Homeschool Quick-Start Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.