Is Standardized Testing Optional for Maryland Homeschoolers?

Parents new to Maryland homeschooling often assume that standardized testing is a mandatory part of compliance — an annual requirement they need to schedule and prepare for. It is not. Standardized testing in Maryland is completely optional for homeschooled students under Option 1 (direct county supervision), and the decision to participate or not has no impact on the legal standing of your home instruction program.

Understanding exactly how testing works in Maryland — when it applies, what it replaces, and why most families skip it — helps you make an informed choice rather than defaulting to an assumption.

The Legal Baseline: Portfolio Review Is the Default

Under COMAR 13A.10.01, the standard mechanism for demonstrating compliance with Maryland's home instruction requirements is the portfolio review. The county superintendent or their representative reviews a portfolio of your child's work up to three times per year (typically twice) to confirm that "regular, thorough instruction" is occurring in the eight required subjects.

Standardized testing is offered as an alternative to — or supplement for — portfolio review, but it is not required, and choosing not to test does not create any compliance problem. The state's default assumption is that you are fulfilling your obligations through the portfolio process.

How the Testing Opt-In Works

If you want your homeschooled child to participate in public school standardized testing, you must request it on the original Home Instruction Notification form (Form 77R) submitted to the local superintendent at the start of your program. The notification form includes a checkbox or section where parents can request standardized test participation.

This opt-in must be made at the beginning of the program — you cannot simply show up at a testing site mid-year and request participation for a current school year. If you did not check the testing box when you filed your initial notification, your child does not have standardized test access for that program year.

Parents who want to add testing in a subsequent year typically need to submit a new or amended notification for that year's program. Contact your county's home instruction coordinator to confirm the process, as logistics vary slightly by jurisdiction.

What Testing Access Provides

When a parent opts into public school testing, their homeschooled child can participate in the Maryland Comprehensive Assessment Program (MCAP) or other standardized assessments administered by the public school system. Testing is conducted at the school site on the public school testing schedule.

The practical benefits of testing access are limited for most Option 1 families. Standardized test results can:

• Serve as an alternative form of academic documentation for portfolio purposes (some counties will accept test results in lieu of or alongside work sample portfolios)
• Provide external benchmarking data if you want to know how your child's skills compare to public school peers
• Satisfy certain dual enrollment or concurrent enrollment programs that require standardized test scores as part of their admissions process

What Testing Access Does Not Provide

Participation in public school testing does not exempt you from the portfolio review process. The county can still conduct portfolio reviews regardless of whether your child tested. Testing is an additional option — it does not replace the requirement to maintain documentation of regular, thorough instruction.

Test results also cannot be used by a reviewer to find your program deficient. If your child scores below grade level on a standardized test, that result does not constitute evidence of insufficient instruction under COMAR. Reviewers are evaluating whether instruction is occurring, not whether it is producing specific academic outcomes as measured against public school benchmarks.

Why Most Maryland Homeschool Families Skip Testing

The majority of Option 1 families in Maryland do not opt into public school standardized testing, and the reasons are practical rather than ideological.

The portfolio is easier. A well-organized portfolio of work samples and subject logs already satisfies the review requirement. Adding standardized testing creates additional scheduling obligations — test dates are set by the school system, occur at a school site, and require advance coordination — without meaningfully reducing the portfolio documentation burden.

Testing benchmarks do not apply. Because COMAR explicitly prohibits reviewers from evaluating instruction against public school academic standards, there is no regulatory benefit to demonstrating grade-level performance on a standardized measure. Testing would only matter for compliance purposes if a bad outcome could be used against you — and it cannot.

Curriculum differences make standardized tests a poor fit. Families using classical, Charlotte Mason, unschooling, or other non-traditional approaches often find that public school standardized tests assess a specific scope and sequence that their curriculum deliberately does not follow. A child who has studied Latin, logic, and narrative history through primary sources may not perform as well on a test designed around public school math and reading pacing — even if their actual education is rigorous and thorough.

Privacy. Opting into public school testing means your child's assessment data enters the public school system's records. Families who value the privacy of the Option 1 framework often prefer to keep all documentation within the portfolio process.

Testing and High School: A Separate Consideration

The testing question becomes more relevant at the high school level, but for different reasons than state compliance. Colleges and universities typically require SAT or ACT scores from homeschooled applicants as part of their admissions evaluation. These are independent testing programs — not Maryland public school assessments — and they are administered through College Board and ACT separately from any state-level testing opt-in.

Maryland homeschooled students can register for the SAT, ACT, or AP exams directly through those organizations as private candidates. No state opt-in is required. High school homeschoolers who plan to apply to selective colleges should focus their testing preparation on these national assessments rather than on Maryland state testing programs.

Dual enrollment — taking community college courses while still in a home instruction program — is widely available in Maryland and does not typically require standardized test scores as a condition of enrollment. Montgomery College, for example, uses placement assessments administered by the college itself rather than requiring prior state test results.

The Portfolio Is Your Real Compliance Tool

Whether or not you participate in standardized testing, the portfolio is the legal foundation of your compliance with Maryland's home instruction regulations. It is the document the county reviews, the evidence you submit if a deficiency notice is issued, and the record that protects you if a review goes wrong.

Building a portfolio that covers all eight COMAR-required subjects — with dated work samples distributed across the semester — is the work that actually matters for Option 1 compliance. Standardized testing is optional, supplemental, and for most families, unnecessary.

The Maryland Portfolio and Assessment Templates provide fillable tracking logs for all eight required subjects, including the non-core subjects (art, music, health, and physical education) most frequently missing from homeschool portfolios. The templates are organized around what Maryland county reviewers are actually looking for — so the documentation you maintain throughout the year is exactly what you need when the review date arrives.

See more United States homeschool guides →