Best Homeschool States: How Pennsylvania Compares to Easier Alternatives

If you have been researching homeschooling in Pennsylvania, you have probably stumbled across lists ranking states by how family-friendly their homeschool laws are. Pennsylvania almost never lands near the top of those lists — and the reasons why are genuinely important to understand before you start (or continue) homeschooling in the Commonwealth.

This post breaks down exactly where Pennsylvania sits in the national landscape, compares it directly to neighboring and commonly cited "easy" homeschool states, and explains what those differences mean in practical terms for your family's compliance burden.

How States Are Classified

Legal and advocacy organizations typically classify states into three tiers based on their documentation and oversight requirements:

Low regulation states require no notification, no testing, no portfolio, and no external review. Parents are essentially trusted to educate their children without state interference.

Moderate regulation states require some notification or an annual assessment, but give families significant flexibility in how they demonstrate educational progress.

High regulation states require multiple layers of compliance: formal filing, detailed documentation, standardized testing, and external review by a qualified evaluator or agency.

Pennsylvania is firmly in the high regulation category. It sits alongside New York, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and Vermont as one of the most administratively demanding homeschool environments in the country.

Pennsylvania's Requirements at a Glance

Under 24 PA C.S. §13-1327.1, Pennsylvania home education supervisors must:

• File a notarized affidavit (or unsworn declaration) with the local school district superintendent each year, including the names of all students, the home education address, and immunization documentation
• Submit an outline of educational objectives by subject area (though this outline cannot be used against you in a compliance challenge)
• Provide instruction in a long list of mandatory subjects, including one that surprises most families: regular and continuous instruction in fire prevention
• Maintain a contemporaneous reading log designating instructional materials by title
• Document 180 days of instruction, or 900/990 hours depending on grade level
• Administer standardized testing in grades 3, 5, and 8
• Hire a qualified private evaluator — a certified teacher or licensed psychologist — for an annual portfolio review
• Submit the evaluator's certification letter to the superintendent by June 30

That is seven distinct compliance tasks per year. For families new to Pennsylvania from a low-regulation state, the administrative shock is real.

States That Rank as the "Easiest" to Homeschool

New Jersey: The Simplest Neighbor

New Jersey requires nothing. Literally. Parents are not required to notify the state or district, administer standardized tests, hire evaluators, maintain portfolios, or follow a required subject list. The only legal standard is that education must be "equivalent" to public school instruction, and the state essentially leaves that determination entirely to parents.

New Jersey consistently ranks as one of the top two or three "easiest" homeschool states in the country. For families who prioritize maximum educational freedom with minimum administrative burden, it is genuinely difficult to argue against.

The tradeoff: New Jersey's lack of structure can be disorienting for families who want external accountability or are building toward college admissions, since there is no formal documentation trail established by law.

Delaware: Low Barrier, Annual Report Only

Delaware requires homeschooling families to submit an annual report of enrollment and attendance to the Department of Education. There is no portfolio requirement, no mandatory testing, no required subject list, and no evaluator review.

For Pennsylvania families near the Delaware border — particularly those in Chester, Delaware, or Cecil County areas — Delaware's framework represents a dramatically lighter compliance load.

Ohio: Moderate but Manageable

Ohio sits in the moderate category. Families must submit a written notification and a brief outline of intended curriculum. Annual assessment is required, but families can choose between a standardized test or a portfolio review — making it more flexible than Pennsylvania's combined requirement. There is no mandatory evaluator. The subject list is less exhaustive.

Ohio's framework gives families meaningful accountability without the intensive annual compliance cycle Pennsylvania demands. For families moving between the two states, Ohio is a notably easier environment.

Maryland: Portfolio Review Without the Audit Culture

Maryland requires notification and offers several assessment options, including portfolio review through an umbrella school or a local district review. There is no mandated standardized testing, and the evaluation culture is generally less adversarial than in Pennsylvania.

Maryland's umbrella school system — where private organizations supervise portfolio review on behalf of the state — insulates families from direct district interaction entirely. Many families find this a more comfortable arrangement than Pennsylvania's direct superintendent relationship.

What Makes Pennsylvania Distinctly Harder

Beyond the sheer number of requirements, Pennsylvania has specific characteristics that amplify the compliance burden:

The evaluator market: Families must independently find and hire a qualified evaluator each year, at fees ranging from $50 to over $200. The evaluator must meet specific statutory qualifications — not just any willing adult qualifies. In some regions, finding an evaluator who aligns philosophically with your approach requires significant research.

District overreach: Even though Act 196 of 2014 eliminated the district's right to review portfolios directly, many school administrators — particularly in suburban Philadelphia and rural districts unfamiliar with the 2014 law changes — still attempt to demand portfolio inspections, excess medical documentation, or test scores. Navigating these unlawful demands requires parents to know their rights in detail.

The fire prevention requirement: Pennsylvania is one of very few states that explicitly mandates fire safety as a continuously taught subject. While the instruction itself is not burdensome, the documentation requirement catches families off guard every year.

The 72% enrollment surge: Between 2019 and 2025, Pennsylvania's home education enrollment grew by 72%, reaching over 44,000 students. District administrators and evaluators are dealing with exponentially more families, and the administrative friction has grown accordingly.

So Should You Homeschool in Pennsylvania?

If you are currently in Pennsylvania, the answer to whether it is a "good" homeschool state depends less on the ranking and more on how well you understand the system. Pennsylvania's requirements are demanding — but they are also clearly defined. The statute tells you exactly what must be in the portfolio, exactly what the evaluator must certify, and exactly what the district may and may not do.

Families who struggle with Pennsylvania homeschooling are usually those who either do not know their legal rights and over-comply with unauthorized district requests, or who wait until May to build a portfolio that should have been assembled incrementally throughout the year.

Families who thrive in Pennsylvania's system understand that the compliance burden is finite and predictable. Annual evaluation by a private evaluator is not an adversarial process when your portfolio is well organized. The standardized testing requirement in grades 3, 5, and 8 has no minimum passing score. The district never sees your portfolio. Once you understand the system, the annual documentation cycle becomes routine.

How Pennsylvania Families Make It Work

The most effective strategy for minimizing Pennsylvania's compliance burden is consistent, incremental record-keeping throughout the year. Families who track reading materials weekly, photograph student work monthly, and mark an attendance calendar as they go arrive at June with a portfolio that essentially assembled itself.

The second most effective strategy is understanding exactly what to include — and what to leave out. Pennsylvania evaluators consistently advise that three to five work samples per subject, drawn from the beginning, middle, and end of the year, demonstrate sustained progress more effectively than a binder overflowing with every worksheet produced since September.

Our Pennsylvania Portfolio and Assessment Templates provide the structured forms, attendance grids, contemporaneous reading logs, and evaluator-ready dividers that make this incremental process manageable — regardless of your curriculum philosophy or whether you are in year one or year ten of homeschooling in the Commonwealth.

Pennsylvania is not the easiest state to homeschool in. But it is a predictable one — and with the right organizational system, that predictability becomes a genuine advantage.

See more United States homeschool guides →